The world of vinyl records has seen a remarkable resurgence in recent years, and with it, the demand for high-quality turntables has skyrocketed. Two of the most respected brands in the industry, Audio-Technica and Pioneer, have released their latest contenders for turntable supremacy: the AT-LP140XP and the PLX-500. In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll delve into the intricacies of these two exceptional turntables and determine which one emerges as the ultimate victor.

Design and Build Quality

The AT-LP140XP boasts a sleek and modern design with a matte black finish. Its sturdy construction ensures stability and durability, while the anti-vibration feet effectively minimize unwanted resonances. On the other hand, the PLX-500 exudes a more classic aesthetic with its silver finish and wooden plinth. Its heavy-duty construction and adjustable feet provide exceptional isolation from external vibrations.

Cartridge and Stylus

The AT-LP140XP comes equipped with the Audio-Technica AT-VM95E cartridge and stylus, renowned for its excellent tracking and detailed sound reproduction. The PLX-500 features the Ortofon OM Black cartridge and stylus, known for its pristine clarity and accurate bass response. Both cartridges are user-replaceable, allowing for future upgrades or customization.

Drive System and Speed Control

The AT-LP140XP utilizes a direct-drive motor for precise speed control and reduced wow and flutter. It supports both 33 1/3 and 45 RPM speeds, with a built-in strobe light for accurate speed adjustment. The PLX-500 also employs a direct-drive motor, ensuring stable platter rotation and minimal speed variations. It offers a wider speed range, including 78 RPM for vintage records.

Tonearm and Anti-Skating

The AT-LP140XP features a J-shaped tonearm with a hydraulic lift and anti-skate mechanism. The tonearm’s low mass and high precision contribute to accurate tracking and minimal distortion. The PLX-500 boasts a straight tonearm with a universal headshell, allowing for easy cartridge swapping. Its advanced anti-skating system ensures optimal tracking force for both conical and elliptical styli.

Connectivity and Features

The AT-LP140XP offers a variety of connectivity options, including RCA phono outputs, a USB output for digital conversion, and a built-in phono preamp for direct connection to non-phono inputs. The PLX-500 provides RCA phono outputs and a USB output, but lacks a built-in phono preamp. Both turntables feature a headphone output for private listening.

Sound Quality

When it comes to sound quality, both the AT-LP140XP and the PLX-500 deliver exceptional performance. The AT-LP140XP produces a well-balanced sound with a wide soundstage and tight bass response. The PLX-500 offers a more neutral and detailed sound, with a focus on accurate reproduction of the original recording.

Recommendations: The Verdict

In a close battle of audiophile supremacy, the Audio-Technica AT-LP140XP emerges as the victor by a narrow margin. Its combination of excellent sound quality, versatile features, and user-friendly design make it the ideal choice for both novice and seasoned vinyl enthusiasts. While the Pioneer PLX-500 offers exceptional sound reproduction and a classic aesthetic, its lack of a built-in phono preamp and limited connectivity options may be drawbacks for some users. Ultimately, the choice between these two exceptional turntables depends on individual preferences and specific requirements.

Answers to Your Most Common Questions

Q: Which turntable is better for beginners?
A: The AT-LP140XP is a more beginner-friendly turntable due to its ease of setup, built-in phono preamp, and user-replaceable cartridge.

Q: Which turntable has a wider speed range?
A: The PLX-500 supports a wider speed range, including 78 RPM for vintage records.

Q: Does the AT-LP140XP have a built-in phono preamp?
A: Yes, the AT-LP140XP features a built-in phono preamp for direct connection to non-phono inputs.

Q: Which turntable has a more classic aesthetic?
A: The PLX-500 exudes a more classic aesthetic with its silver finish and wooden plinth.

Q: Which turntable is more suitable for audiophiles?
A: Both turntables offer exceptional sound quality, but the PLX-500 may be a better choice for audiophiles who prioritize neutral and detailed reproduction.